Posted by: alexdberg | November 3, 2008

Japanese in-group culture and telepathy

I was reading a blog by another guy that lives in Tokyo, and he told an interesting story. His story tells about how he wandered into an unfamiliar bar one night, which is normal for him, except this bar seemed particularly unfriendly. But this time, however, when he tried to order a drink, the bartender grabbed him by the arm, threw him out of the bar, and told him, “No foreigners”. Pretty hardcore racism, right?

This story got me thinking about the Japanese culture. Japan is really heavy on the “in-group” thing. Everyone is part of a group. This is why Japanese corporations are some of the strangest in the world. They never really fire their employees, because they are part of the family. Instead, they just give them a desk with no work to do, and wait for them to quit (according to what I have heard). It is a rare thing for a  Japanese salaryman to switch companies. If you get a job at a new company, they WILL have a hard time truly trusting you. They have an in-group mentality, so if you haven’t been working together with them in the same corporate family, you will be assumed to not really know anything. How could you? Your old company’s culture is guaranteed to be different from this new company’s culture.

I have no real experience of working for a Japanese company, I am just basing it all on hearsay and what I have read from books, but it is still interesting enough for me to develop a theory/explanation. My best guess/theory: The Japanese language and culture is very context-sensitive. It is so guarded by social rules and social etiquette that people commonly say that the Japanese are telepathic. They are able to guess and respond to the other party’s words before they speak, almost like playing a whole conversation in their minds. It is because of this “telepathy” that these in-group cultures easily form. If you can’t do telepathy with the Japanese (because you are an outsider) then they WILL not accept you as quickly as they would have otherwise.

Next time Japan confuses you, try thinking about this in-group culture. Maybe it explains why they love you, hate you, or ignore you.


Responses

  1. I was sort of taken aback by your article since I have always known Japanese people as good-natured and peaceful beings. Maybe I’m just one of the lucky ones who have never encountered anything seriously offensive that might cause me to think otherwise. I have been a witness to what you call the in-group mentality of the Japanese people but I have viewed it as something constructive. As for the workplace, there might be some truth to the things you have heard and read about but I guess it is just a matter of learning how to blend in with these people if you are a foreigner. And the same rule applies to any other country that we go to, I believe. We will always find something peculiar with other nationalities as they will always find something strange with us!

    Cheers! :)

  2. Hey, don’t be taken aback too much, I love all of the Japanese I have met so far! I just thought that I would report some textbook theory with some real life situation. The story told by a fellow blogger, The Ghost, really surprised me, so I wanted to try to explain their behavior.

    In case you missed the link up top, here is the story I was responding to:

    http://theghostletters.blogspot.com/2008/10/gaijin-not-welcomed-heresorry.html

    Thanks for stopping by to comment! Take it easy!


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories